Soziologie und Kriminologie – Offener Zugang
Offener Zugang

Abstrakt

The Exclusion of Serious and Organized Offenders and their Victims from the Offer of Restorative Justice

Nikki Joanna

There is scarce research evidence of restorative justice getting used within the context of major and organized crime offending. This study sought to explore the feasibility of using restorative justice by canvassing the views of experts, serious and organized crime offenders and high and organized crime victims in England. Offenders and victims got the chance to interact during a restorative justice initiative and individual cases were pursued accordingly as a series of case studies. Case studies were limited to large-scale serious and organized fraud. Stark differences in views were apparent between serious and organized crime experts and restorative justice experts, the previous doubting offenders' motivations and pointing to their dangerousness without fully considering victim perspectives. Despite high attrition rates among some offenders expressing an initial willingness to pursue restorative justice, where both parties wished to participate, sustained motivation was observed. This study highlights inequities within the way that police forces have implemented the 2015 Victims Code requirements for restorative justice in England and Wales, potentially blocking opportunities for closure, social integration and reduced reoffending.